?

Log in

No account? Create an account
device

Strangers in Gilead

Posted on 2007.09.28 at 18:54

Comments:


hiyacynth
hiyacynth at 2007-10-07 19:18 (UTC) (Link)
Oh, hell yes. That was amazing. Have just recc'd the heck out of it to my flist, many of whom often say what the world needs now is Winchesters in the Old West. God. SO GOOD. I loved the way you managed to get so much information and characterization across from the outsider perspective (let's hear it for peepholes, eh?), and how you let the slow reveal of what was going on, how they got there, etc. build. I anticipated losing interest because we weren't going to SEE a lot of the action take place, but I never did. The tension was tight throughout, and man alive, when the action did come home, you brought it. That fight--perfect for the Winchester reunion--was a thing of beauty. Um. As were all those lovely scenes in and around that bathtub. OMG and the glory of Sam buying his brother some company for the evening, and then trying to have a civilized conversation while Dean's getting it on, loudly, next door. Too precious, I tell you. And THANK YOU for that lovely set of scenes with Sam and Miss Rose. Sam girl that I am, I gotta say that I loved every single thing about it.

Okay. I really have to go do my homework now. Why I decided grad school was a good idea when there's fic to be read I can't say. But there it is. Thank you for a marvelous read.
Corvus Imbrifer
corvus_imbrifer at 2007-11-29 23:03 (UTC) (Link)
I just glanced back over my comment lists and don't see a response to your comment. My apologies!

I'm so glad you enjoyed the story. Particularly the Sam characterization, that's so important to get right. (And often neglected in the show, if you ask me.)

Hope school is going well!
Previous Entry  Next Entry